I wrote, several years ago, about my lack of desire to have children. “You wait until you hit thirty,” other women would tell me. “You’ll change your mind.” Now that I’ve reached thirty, and with the idea of the childless writer being in the media a lot recently, it seems like a good time to readdress the issue.
Of course, all those people who told me I was going to change my mind didn’t mean that on my thirtieth birthday I would suddenly be overcome by the urge to procreate. Most of them still stand by their opinion that at some stage I’m going to change my mind. And for my part, I’m still prepared for the fact that I could. But honestly, I’m still not feeling the urge. I still don’t think I’ll ever be willing to make the commitment.
The way people react when I tell them I don’t want children has changed as I’ve got older. Many people respect my stance, but I still get a lot of people who don’t quite believe it. At the moment, they mostly think I’ll change my mind, but as the window for mind-changing grows smaller, I find that people react with more judgement, more incredulity than they did before. “Really?” they say, their eyes wide, and I know that I’m only a few years away from being judged by society for my decision.
This article in The Telegraph last week, provokingly entitled, “If Maeve Binchy had been a mother...” raised a reassuring amount of outrage on my Twitter stream. The underlying sentiment of the article was that Maeve Binchy could never be as good a writer – or indeed as empathetic a person – as she could have been because she had not experienced a fundamental part of womanhood. The article, to be fair to it, was quite confused and managed to tangle up a few conflicting points of view. However, the sentiment behind it was offensive, and like many female writers, I was outraged to see it published in a national newspaper. Not least because it was written by a woman.
I have huge amounts of admiration for all the women I follow on Twitter who raise families, hold down day jobs and still put a huge amount of energy into their writing. But I don’t think being mothers automatically makes them better writers. I don’t feel like my decision not to have children makes me less of a human being; nor do I believe that it will mean I can never achieve my potential as a writer.
Some women are able to cope with the combination motherhood and writing. It’s not easy, but they manage it. I’m not sure that I would be one of those women. I think, for me, something would have to give. Of course, you never know until you’re in a situation; maybe I’d find in myself strength and determination that I didn’t know I had. But I don’t think I want to find out. Things happen without planning of course, and people cope. I, I assume, would cope. But going out of my way to engineer the situation? I just don’t feel that that will work for me.
What worries me now is the stigma attached to choosing not to have children. It’s a decision I’m expected to justify, something I’m supposed to feel ashamed of. I should be proud to know myself well enough to make a decision that takes me away from the mainstream. And I am, but I’m starting to feel the need to remind myself.
Image by Cveleglg